How disneys new jungle book subverts rudyard kiplings. Disney is bringing back the jungle book in a liveaction remake, but worries over racial stereotyping that plagued the 1967 cartoon original are. Before the jungle book opened at the goodman theatre, director mary zimmerman gave an interview with catey sullivan in chicago magazine about how she handled the racism in kipling and disneys source material. The jungle book is just as drenched with racism and colonialism as anything else kipling wrote on the subject. Disneys overall point, i would not agree that her granduncle was a rabidly racist, sexist, or antisemitic figure in hollywood. Disney plus adds content warning to animated movies criticized as. How to adapt the jungle book and not make it racist the atlantic. The jungle exposes multiple aspects of the cost of poor working conditions in chicago. Student slams the jungle book and other classic disney films for. According to amanda bells article on yahoo, kipling was a racist. Professors are demanding that the walt disney company make a less racist version of the beloved cartoon film, jungle book, which depicted a society of apes that was obviously meant to demean black people, according to academia. Specifically, the most obvious depiction of race in the jungle book comes with the monkeys. Cmon he made a film jungle book about how you should stay with your own kind at the height of the fight over.
Netflix just announced a new liveaction adaptation of rudyard kiplings the jungle book. Well, some critics apparently believe what the animated classic really was telling us is that the king louie the ape represented an african american who is singing i want to be like you with the you in this case referring to caucasian whites as represented by the human character mowgli. The jungle book has long been politically discomforting. In defense of rudyard kipling and the jungle books. Disney is bringing back the jungle book in a liveaction remake, but worries over racial stereotyping that plagued the 1967 cartoon original are already making critics fret the film, which. The new jungle book tries to bypass racism by erasing identities altogether author media diversified posted on april 29, 2016 june 20, 2016 categories history, hollywood, literature, media, rajeev balasubramanyam, tv and film tags colonialism, india, jon favreau, jungle book, rudyard kipling. Along the way, he confronts a variety of hostile wildlife and humans and figures out where he belongs. The jungle book has made britain nation of passive. Is the latest liveaction adaptation of jungle book. Escaping rudyard kiplings legacy the british author famous for the jungle book 1894, has been the subject of scholarly debate about his. When the book came out in early march, few seemed to notice anything wrong. A childs search for father transcends jungle books racism. With legend of tarzan generating buzz courtesy of its wellreceived teaser trailer, the longdebated issue of whether tarzan creator edgar rice burroughs was a racist has come alive on discussion boards and comment threads. Unlike the majority of the adapted characters in the film, louie was not featured in rudyard kiplings original works.
Rudyard kipling, who came up with the story of the orphaned indian boy, and walt disney, whose studio has made an inflationadjusted gross in. But its not minstrel shows and blatant racism either. The monkeys enter the plot swinging through the indian forest in search of mowgli, the man cub. Unlike the majority of the adapted characters in the. Or, as slate chimed in, its fine to like disneys new. Bell doesnt bother to prove her accusations of racism, but assumes they are correct.
In defense of rudyard kipling and the jungle books the. New jungle book adapters cant claim the same obliviousness. British indiaborn writer and poet rudyard kipling is seen as a controversial figure in modern times due to his imperialistic views and his poem if has been branded racist. I would, however, not deny that he displayed casually bigoted tendencies that only further place him as a man of his time. Disneys new liveaction version of the 1967 film will have to take great care not to cause offence, critics say. Its worth noting that the new jungle book flick wont just have to overcome the issues of racism plaguing the 1967 animated version. Well, kipling was certainly a racist fucklook no further than his novel kim for a portrait of brave british spies and slavish, darkskinned buddhistsbut the jungle book. But the mowgli stories are the heart of the books, and it is to them that we turn to gauge the extent and nature of the jungle books racism as well as that of their author. The british author famous for the jungle book 1894, has been the subject of scholarly debate about his proimperialist ideas and themes interlaced in his body of work.
Many critics believe that the book and its sequel are filled with imperialist symbolism. The jungle book and racism in disneys animated features. The jungle book and the racism present in empires november 22, 2016 december 3, 2016 thesuneversets a sad yet inherent aspect of empires is the prevalence of racism and bigotry that has developed by many of the imperialist powers that colonize a new region or population of people and call it their own. Race representation in the jungle book howlround theatre. How mary zimmerman handled kiplings racism and misogyny in a new the jungle book musical, chicago magazine, section goes here. Lauren robertson, from aberdeen university, has branded the likes of the lady and the tramp and dumbo as dodgy and says they have not. The jungle book the classic disney animated film based on the story by rudyard kipling is scheduled to be remade into a liveaction film. The jungle books complicated relationship with imperialism. How to adapt the jungle book and not make it racist. While one can argue that its not fair to apply 21st century standards or racial awareness to a 1912 story and its author.
The movie was also quite problematic for those who decried. The original animated version of disneys jungle book was deemed racist and the author rudyard kipling was a vocal defender of colonialism. King louie is a fictional character introduced in walt disneys 1967 animated musical film, the jungle book. But i think you have to look for racism in the jungle book, and that you will find it only if you desperately want to. The most racist moments in disney cartoons complex. Disneys track record in this area was hardly unblemished, from the jabbering crows in dumbo to song of the south, and by the mid1960s. Especially in the jungle book, animals depict different races and contribute to the social understanding of race. The new jungle book tries to bypass racism by erasing. The jungle book was originally written to prove that white.
While the book was written in the late 1800s, disneys film adaptation wasnt released until 1967, right in the heart of the civil rights movement. Walt disneys grandniece agrees with meryl streep racist. The racism in kiplings writing extends beyond his poetry. Disney plus adds disclaimer about racist movie stereotypes ap news. Racism has always been a part of american history, and people who say we live in a postracial america are so full of shit that its easy to disregard anything they say from then on. This paper will examine two disney animated films that feature characters apparently depicting black stereotypes.
What kipling claimed in the jungle book and kim is that a britisheuropean person could become one of the indians and yet still be separate from them, as well as able to go back to his previous. Jamil khoury called zimmerman out on her reckless, unexamined orientalism in response to that interview. King louie was portrayed as an orangutan who was the leader of the other jungle primates, and who attempted to gain knowledge of fire from mowgli, in order. Rudyard kiplings the jungle book, left, edgar rice burroughs tarzan of the apes, and agatha chrisites ten little indians are inherently racist, according to john barnes. Negotiating race, racism and orientalism in the jungle book on stage. The thread running throughout the stories is that mowgli is superior to the animals. He learns all about the jungle and its inhabitants and ways of life, and he can do so in large measure because all the animals. Did you catch the subtle racism in disneys the princess and the frog. Perceptions of race in three generations of the jungle book. Racism warning on remake of jungle book film film the.
236 603 32 299 578 322 462 904 686 378 451 888 1420 59 1169 329 518 1165 328 64 423 1496 497 1553 1122 1061 1194 1030 537 714 841 813 1485 502 37 889 561